Saturday, April 26, 2008
Well, I figured I should do this since I'm already running out of disk space from keeping multiple copies of anime episodes...
So, here it is for VK. I can't wait for the Conclave-Diffusion one, I'm so running out of space already......
~
Personal Opinion:
Weeeelll... Basically, Ureshii released an HD version, so that's a very big plus for me... Their video also seems to have... er... richer color. :D Though all in all, VK isn't very rich in color at all... Lalala~ Their karaoke effects were also the nicest, IMO. :D Can't say much about TL since I didn't really watch this and I don't really know Jap.
Shoku-Dan is the fastest. Decent job for a sort of speedsub seemingly done by (going by their credits) only two people.. :o well, I guess that is possible. After all, all of the people in our *ahem* severely inactive group are capable of everything except translating. Hahaha. Well, I'm only capabe of basic encoding though, no avisynth or anything.. Anywaaay...
I guess Mishicorp has better vid qual than Shoku-Dan, but, well, they do release later than Shoku... Hmm... I don't like their OP Karaoke--too flashy. I guess they have better TL than Shoku-Dan, but, well, Shoku-Dan is the faster one, soo.. Well, they call those tradeoffs.
In the end, I think I'll go for Ureshii because, well, they're HD. :D
~
--------Various Details-------
Ureshii
===========================================
1280x720 :: H.264 :: mkv :: ASS :: Vorbis :: ~350 MB ::
***
TL: Fakia
Time: mreweilk
Edit: Collectr
TS: Borjoyze
Kara: cuac
Raw: House
Encode: Dragon5152
QC: Blue_Mage
Fatsobob
-------------------------------------------
Mishicorp
===========================================
704x400 :: H.264 :: mkv :: ASS :: AAC :: ~174 MB ::
***
TL: IG
Time: Franky-
Edit: Digiboy123
Nojiko
TS: Msr
Kara: Mr_Kudo
Raw:
Encode: Xarda
QC: Amentia
Pingu
Logo: Nojiko
[m]
-------------------------------------------
Shoku-Dan
===========================================
704x396 :: Xvid :: avi :: Hardsubbed :: MP3 :: ~150 MB
***
TL: Touyuki
Time: Raserei Hojo
Edit: Raserei Hojo
TS:
Kara: Raserei Hojo
Raw:
Encode: Raserei Hojo
QC:
Distro: Raserei Hojo
(These are credits for ep.2 since I already deleted ep.1)
-------------------------------------------
~
Here are screens from the OP (PNG except for the third one):
(I can only compare OP/ED since I already deleted Shoku-Dan's ep1)

~
Disclaimer/Whatever-this-is-supposed-to-be-called:
- VK and its characters belong to their rightful owners. Matsuri Hino-san, LaLa, Hana to Yume, Studio Deen, TV Tokyo, etc. I certainly and definitely do not claim it/them to be my own.
- The fansub group's works are theirs and theirs alone, and most definitely not mine. I'm just comparing them and all that. If anything I did was illegal or something like that, I would take this post down as soon as I am informed.
- This is in no way at all the absolute truth! The opinions presented here are merely, well, opinions (Circular definition--BANG!). I am not criticizing or trying to put down anyone/any group. No offense meant at all. Just stating my opinions here. If this is beyond my supposed freedom of expression, I shall obliterate this post immediately after I am informed. Yay for fansubs!!!
- Let's all wish for infinite disk space!!!
Well, that's all for this one~ ^_____^




0 violent reactions:
Post a Comment